Should I keep both Amex Platinum and Chase Sapphire Reserve?

Keep both cards only if your combined benefit usage exceeds the combined $1,245 annual fees. Calculate ROI separately for each card: total benefits used minus annual fee. If one card has negative ROI, consider downgrading or canceling it. Many travelers find value in both for complementary benefits (Centurion Lounges + 3x dining), but track actual usage to be sure.

How do I track benefits across multiple premium cards?

Track each card separately with its own benefit checklist and expiration dates. Note which benefits overlap (both have Priority Pass) vs. which are unique (only Platinum has Centurion Lounges). Calculate ROI per card, not combined, so you can make independent retention decisions. Apps like kardfolio can track multiple cards with separate dashboards.

Which premium card should I cancel first if I need to reduce fees?

Cancel the card with the lowest ROI (benefits used minus annual fee). If Amex Platinum gives you $600 value on a $695 fee (negative ROI) while CSR gives $700 on $550 (positive ROI), cancel the Platinum. Before canceling, call for retention offers and consider downgrade paths to preserve credit history.

Do Amex Platinum and CSR benefits overlap?

Yes, some benefits overlap: both include Priority Pass lounge access, Global Entry credit, and travel insurance. Unique to Platinum: Centurion Lounges, hotel elite status, Uber credits, Saks credit. Unique to CSR: 3x dining earning, primary rental car insurance, simpler $300 travel credit. When calculating ROI, count overlapping benefits only once.

When should I make retention decisions for premium cards?

Review each card 30-60 days before your annual fee posts. Calculate your ROI from the past year, call for retention offers, and decide whether to keep, downgrade, or cancel. Most issuers refund the annual fee if you cancel within 30-41 days of it posting. Track benefit usage year-round so you have data ready at renewal time.

Managing Amex Platinum & Chase Sapphire Reserve Together

You have two premium travel cards totaling $1,245/year in fees. Here's how to track benefits across both, calculate your true ROI, and decide what to keep at renewal time.

Last updated: December 2025

The Real Question

You're not asking "which card should I get?" — you already have them. The question is: are both worth keeping?

Combined annual fees: $1,245/year ($695 Platinum + $550 CSR). Are you getting $1,245+ in value? Let's find out.

Benefits That Overlap (Don't Double Count)

When you have both cards, some benefits are redundant. Count these only once in your ROI calculation:

Priority Pass lounge access — Both cards include it. You only need one membership.
Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit — Both offer ~$100 every 4-5 years. You only need one.
Travel insurance — Coverage is similar. Use whichever card you booked travel with.
No foreign transaction fees — Both have this. No added value from having two.

Key insight: If Priority Pass is your main lounge benefit, you don't need both cards for it.

Unique Benefits Worth Tracking Separately

Only on Amex Platinum ($695/year)

Centurion Lounge access (the premium lounge benefit)
Delta Sky Club access (when flying Delta)
Marriott Gold + Hilton Gold status
$200 Uber Cash/year
$200 airline fee credit
$600 hotel credit ($300/half via FHR/Hotel Collection)
$100 Saks credit
$300 Equinox credit
Entertainment credits (Disney+, etc.)

Only on Chase Sapphire Reserve ($550/year)

3x points on dining (Platinum earns only 1x)
3x points on all travel (more flexible than Platinum's 5x flights-only)
Primary rental car insurance (Platinum is secondary)
$300 travel credit (simpler to use than Platinum's credits)
DoorDash benefits

Calculate ROI for Each Card Separately

Don't calculate combined ROI. Calculate each card independently so you can make separate retention decisions.

Amex Platinum ROI Worksheet

Benefit	Available	You Used
Uber Cash	$200	$____
Airline Fee Credit	$200	$____
Hotel Credit	$600	$____
Saks Credit	$100	$____
Centurion Lounge visits (@ $50 each)	varies	$____
Hotel status upgrades	varies	$____
Other credits used	varies	$____
TOTAL VALUE		$____
Minus Annual Fee		- $695
NET ROI		$____

Chase Sapphire Reserve ROI Worksheet

Benefit	Available	You Used
Travel Credit	$300	$____
Extra points from 3x dining (vs 1x)*	varies	$____
Extra points from 3x travel (vs 1x)*	varies	$____
Rental car insurance savings	varies	$____
DoorDash benefits	$60	$____
TOTAL VALUE		$____
Minus Annual Fee		- $550
NET ROI		$____

*Calculate incremental points value: (spend × bonus rate difference × point value). Example: $10,000 dining × 2% extra × 1.5¢/point = $300 incremental value.

Retention Decision Framework

Both Cards Have Positive ROI

Keep both. You're getting more value than you're paying. Continue tracking to ensure this stays true.

One Card Has Negative ROI

Before canceling, try these steps:

Call for a retention offer. Say you're considering canceling due to the annual fee. Ask if there are any offers to offset it.
Consider a downgrade. Amex Platinum can downgrade to Green. CSR can downgrade to no-fee Freedom cards. This preserves credit history.
Time it right. Cancel within 30-41 days of the annual fee posting for a full refund.

Both Cards Have Negative ROI

You're paying $1,245/year for benefits you're not using. Consider keeping only one (the one closer to break-even) or downgrading both to no-fee alternatives.

Common Scenarios

"I fly a lot but don't dine out much"

Platinum is likely your winner (Centurion Lounges, hotel status, 5x flights). CSR may not be worth it if you're not using 3x dining. Consider downgrading CSR to Freedom Unlimited for 1.5x everything.

"I use both cards for different things"

This is the ideal scenario. Use Platinum for flights and lounges, CSR for dining and rental cars. Track benefits on both to confirm the math works.

"I mostly just want lounge access"

If Centurion Lounges specifically matter, keep Platinum. If any lounge will do, either card works (both have Priority Pass). Calculate which card's other benefits you use more.

"I'm not using either card's benefits fully"

One premium card is probably enough. Keep whichever has better ROI and downgrade the other. Or consider if a mid-tier card (CSP at $95, Amex Gold at $325) would serve you better.

How to Track Benefits Across Multiple Cards

Separate tracking for each card. Don't lump them together. You need independent ROI to make independent decisions.
Note expiration dates. Platinum has monthly (Uber), semi-annual (Saks, hotel), and annual credits. CSR is simpler with just annual travel credit.
Track earning rates too. If you're putting dining on Platinum (1x) instead of CSR (3x), you're leaving money on the table.
Review monthly, decide annually. Track usage throughout the year. Make retention decisions 30-60 days before each annual fee posts.

Bottom Line

Having both Amex Platinum and Chase Sapphire Reserve can make sense — but only if the math works. Track your actual benefit usage for each card separately. Calculate individual ROI. Make retention decisions based on data, not assumptions.

If one card isn't pulling its weight, don't pay $550-695 for benefits you don't use. Downgrade, get a retention offer, or cancel. Your goal is maximizing value from the cards you have, not collecting premium cards.

Track Both Cards in One Dashboard

kardfolio tracks benefits across all your cards with separate ROI calculations for each. See which credits are expiring, which you've used, and whether each card is worth keeping.

Amex Platinum Benefits CSR Benefits Start Tracking Free